Banking Exchange Magazine Logo

Making the most of your HMDA analysis

Fed shows the way to review annual figures

Making the most of  your HMDA analysis

I almost hesitate to write about HMDA again this month, since last month my topic was also about HMDA. If it wasn’t for the fact that it’s so darn important and it keeps jumping out as a subject that needs emphasis—even during these mortgage rules-crazed days just before January 2014.

So,  I just can’t help myself.

Take a page from the Fed, really

On its website, the Federal Reserve Board published an article that examines the 2012 HMDA data from a national perspective. It presents some interesting overview facts about the combined pool of HMDA data from all institutions and what it says about the real estate lending environment in 2012.

The Fed is doing at a global level what every individual HMDA reporting institution should be doing with the HMDA data, and that is analyzing the data and seeing what the data can show us about lending patterns and practices. 

The 2012 pooled HMDA data highlights some key characteristics of last year’s real estate lending activity:

• Mortgage originations (all HMDA-type loans) increased by 38% over 2011

• Refinancings were up 54% over 2011

• Home purchases increased 13% from 2011

• Home improvement loans were up 12% over the previous year

HMDA lending, in general, has been increasing over the past few years since the peak of the pre-crisis years.

Drilling into the detail

Analyzing the HMDA data based on race and ethnicity, the Fed found that, overall, the number of home purchase loans made to all racial and ethnic groups increased.

However, non-Hispanic White borrowers and Asian borrowers had significantly larger increases than Hispanic White borrowers and Black/African American or Native Hawaiian/other Pacific Islander or American Indian/Alaska Native borrowers.

HMDA Table

The Fed also reported that denial rates for home purchase loans overall were higher for Black/African American and Hispanic White borrowers than other groups.

The Fed’s analysis went further and took a portion of the HMDA data from certain reporters and matched it to borrowers’ credit records, which goes beyond the HMDA data and examines subsequent payment performance and other factors that are not captured in HMDA reports.

For example, the Fed found that credit scores of Black/African American and Hispanic White mortgage borrowers at the time of loan origination tend to be lower and subsequent delinquency rates higher than Asian and non-Hispanic White borrowers.

This is just a small taste of what is in the Fed’s report and a small sample of what lenders could and should be doing with their HMDA data (and additional loan file data).

Some things to think about

Can you answer these questions about your 2012 HMDA data?

• What categories of lending increased or decreased over the previous year?

• What are the denial percentages for each racial, ethnic, and gender group?

• Are withdrawn applications excessively high (or increasing significantly)?

• Are HOEPA or higher priced mortgage loans on the rise? Overly represented in certain ethnic, racial, gender or income groups?

• What census tracts in the market are not represented in the bank’s lending portfolio? Under-represented?

Can you add to this list?  What other important questions should be asked?

Nancy Derr-Castiglione

"Lucy and Nancy’s Common Sense Compliance” is blogged by both Lucy Griffin and Nancy Derr-Castiglione, both Banking Exchange contributing editors on compliance. Nancy, a Certified Regulatory Compliance Manager, is owner of D-C Compliance Services, an independent regulatory compliance consulting services business that has provided expertise in compliance training, monitoring, risk assessment, and policies and procedures to financial institutions since 2002. Previously, Nancy held compliance positions with Bank One Corporation and with United Banks of Colorado. In addition to serving as a Contributing Editor of Banking Exchange, Nancy has served on the ABA Compliance Executive Committee; National and Graduate Compliance Schools board; conference planning committees, and the Editorial Advisory Board for the ABA Bank Compliance magazine. She can be reached at [email protected]

back to top


About Us

Connect With Us



How to get the most out of Data and AI
with Ravi Loganathan from Sardine
and President of Sonar

Wednesday, July 24, 2024 at 11 AM ET / 8 AM PT

In this webinar we will cover:


This webinar is brought to you by:

SardineBanking Exchange