Unexpected expenses hit non-prime Boomers hard
Borrowing against retirement plans postpones future
- Written by Steve Cocheo
Tick, tick, tick, tick...
The oldest Baby Boomers are in their early 70s, the youngest are in their early 50s. The “golden years,” and the need for retirement resources, are approaching. But for many non-prime Boomers, tomorrow’s needs are being sacrificed to the present.
New research, “The unGolden Years: Non-prime Baby Boomers,” from the Elevate Center for the New Middle Class indicates that non-prime Boomers are borrowing against their 401k accounts three times as frequently as prime Boomers do. The survey found that 4% of prime Boomers have 401k loans, while 13% of non-prime Boomers have borrowed against these retirement plans.
Frequently these loans are taken out when unexpected financial challenges arise, says Jonathan Walker, executive director of the center.
While borrowing against 401k accounts is completely legitimate, Walker notes that doing so has a way of putting the borrower’s future on hold. Essentially the borrower is losing ground on the retirement front, with less and less time left to build it up. (Elevate, parent of the center, is a fintech that lends online to non-prime borrowers. The center, sponsored by the company, specializes in research and dialog concerning non-prime market segments.)
In the course of his work, Walker spoke with a state employee who told him that his family had been hit with a number of heavy unexpected expenses. He had a solid job, he told Walker, but was scrambling to meet those unforeseen costs. He added that he was glad that it was illegal to borrow against his state retirement fund holdings—he had to get past the rough spot, but at least he wouldn’t affect his future.
This little anecdote illustrates some of the issues uncovered by the study.
Hard to manage, hard to guard against surprises
Less than half—43%—of the non-prime Boomers in the company’s research feel comfortable with their ability to manage their day-to-day finances, let alone prepare for retirement. Not that prime Boomers all feel confident, either, with 76% saying they can manage daily financial needs.
Long-term financial security is anticipated by only one in three non-prime Boomers, while two-thirds of prime Boomers feel confident. Regular savings, practiced by two-thirds of prime Boomers, eludes many non-primer Boomers. Less than a third of them save something monthly, and nearly one in five say they just don’t save, period.
Elevate’s study, based on a survey of over 1,000 prime and nonprime consumers, found that non-prime Boomers are 14 times as likely as prime Boomers to have difficulty predicting monthly income—and 4 in 10 say they live paycheck to paycheck. They also tend to have difficulty predicting monthly expenses and are therefore more likely to experience unexpected expenses, the research says.
Walker says many middle-class Americans feel they are not in financial control. Among non-prime boomers, 7 in 10 run out of money at least once a year, in spite of generally decent employment levels—frequently, in fact, with more than one job apiece.
When faced with financial emergencies
The study asked respondents how they would meet an emergency need for $1,200. Among the non-prime Boomer respondents, nearly half had difficulty coming up with a source of funds—1 in 8 could think of no solution at all. In a related vein, one in five non-prime boomers do no planning ahead for major expenses and slightly more don’t plan for unexpected expenses.
While one of the most striking avenues taken by non-prime Boomers in a financial exigency, 401k loans aren’t the only route taken when these consumers find themselves in financial difficulties.
• 22% of non-prime Boomers could cover the $1,200 surprise through savings—about half of the portion of prime Boomers who could do so.
• 22% said they could use a credit card to cover the surprise, but less than a third said they could pay off that borrowing before it began to accrue interest.
• 11% said they could tap family or friends for the money. Interestingly, only 2% of prime Boomers would go that way.
• A small portion—4.4%—of non-prime Boomers would use payday lenders, deposit advances, or overdraft programs. Interestingly, in a separate question, 13% of non-prime Boomers said they’d used a payday loan in the previous 12 months.
Unexpected expenses—apparently exacerbated by the lack of planning discussed earlier—play havoc with non-prime Boomers finances.
• Medical costs. Non-prime Boomers are 29% more likely than prime Boomers to experience non-routine medical expenses. And 85%of the non-routine expenses came unexpectedly.
• Funeral costs were cited by 30% more non-prime Boomers than prime.
• Legal fees. Legal expenses hit non-prime Boomers three times as often as prime.
Does non-prime life beget more trouble?
In a different portion of the study, respondents were asked about car repairs. The research found that prime Boomers are much more likely to be able to plan ahead—to the degree one can—on auto expenses. Of the prime respondents, 35% of their repairs were “planned,” while only 15% of those incurred by non-prime boomers were.
“The influence of just getting by can affect your life in different ways,” says Walker. Affording a car on a shoestring gets the non-prime borrower to work, but such vehicles, typically older, come with their own issues.
A noise not investigated doesn’t get better generally. In a similar fashion, suggests Walker, medical issues may be put off. Later, they may turn out to have worsened to the point where they can’t be ignored, but have become more severe matters.
Why unsecured loans rank highly
Recent research from TransUnion indicated that many borrowers prioritized unsecured loans—being willing to keep them current even if other forms of credit became delinquent. Walker was asked to consider that finding in light of his own study. [Read, “Credit mystery has experts pondering”]
He suggests that a non-prime borrower will realize that they aren’t likely to get other forms of credit, such as a car loan, but they can’t leave themselves hanging. Maintaining their relationship with a company that has extended a personal loan is important.
“For them, it’s the last line of defense that they are not willing to give up,” says Walker.
Tagged under Consumer Credit, Retail Banking, Risk Management, Customers, Credit Risk, Feature, Feature3,