Banking Exchange Magazine Logo

Second judge declines to rule on fintech charter

Still not ripe: With charter still only a proposal, nothing yet to block, federal court decides

Once again, a federal court has ruled that efforts to quash the proposed fintech national charter are not ripe because the matter remains a proposal. Once again, a federal court has ruled that efforts to quash the proposed fintech national charter are not ripe because the matter remains a proposal.

Following in the wake of a parallel federal case that was dismissed last December, another federal judge has dismissed an attempt by state banking regulators to block OCC’s proposed fintech charter.

On April 30, Judge Dabney Friedrich of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, ruled on multiple legal grounds that the matter was not ripe for a decision. Friedrich was ruling in Conference of State Bank Supervisors v. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.

His decision was a direct reaction to OCC’s request for a dismissal of the suit by CSBS, which represents state banking regulators. He made reference to the dismissal in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, in a suit by the New York State Department of Financial Services.

No injury has occurred

In a key paragraph from his 20-page memorandum opinion, Friedrich ticked off why the CSBS lawsuit was premature: 

“Several contingent and speculative events must occur before the OCC charters a Fintech: (1) the OCC must decide to finalize a procedure for handling those applications; (2) a Fintech company must choose to apply for a charter; (3) the particular Fintech must substantively satisfy regulatory requirements; and (4) the OCC must decide to grant the charter to the particular Fintech. When the complaint was filed, not even the first step—finalized procedures—had occurred.”

Where things stand at OCC

The fintech charter concept was proposed by former Comptroller of the Currency Thomas Curry. The formal proposal has not moved beyond the draft that was released while Curry was still in office.

In early April Joseph Otting, President Trump’s appointee as Comptroller, announced during a government affairs meeting of the Independent Community Bankers of America that OCC would publish its position on the charter within 60-90 days.

In a February interview with Banking Exchange Otting spoke to one attraction of proposed fintech national bank charters—and its flip side. 

Want more banking news and analysis?

Get banking news, insights and solutions delivered to your inbox each week.

“Everybody views preemption as the Holy Grail in that space,” Otting said. “But often they don’t understand what comes with the Holy Grail—requirements for capital, liquidity, compliance, CRA, etc.”

In his remarks at the ICBA meeting, Otting was quoted by Reuters as saying that “We haven’t concluded on the position and we welcome people’s feedback. But I would say that if we did allow fintech to be regulated, they would be subject to the same rules and regulations as other banks.”

States continue to watch charter

In reaction to the latest decision, CSBS President and CEO John Ryan issued a statement.

“We have received a decision from Judge Dabney Friedrich on Conference of State Bank Supervisors vs. Office of Comptroller of the Currency, a case brought in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. The case involves OCC’s efforts to create a national bank charter for non-depository financial technology firms. Such efforts exceed the OCC’s statutory authority, CSBS argued.

“I appreciate Judge Friedrich’s consideration and timely decision on this matter,” said Ryan. “In essence, the Judge decided that the OCC has not made a final decision on proceeding with the fintech charter and, thus, the matter is not yet ripe for consideration. As a result, the Judge did not render a decision on the merits of our case.”

Ryan went on to note that state regulators have been moving ahead with modernization efforts, “promoting access to innovative products while ensuring consumer protection.”

This includes the CSBS Vision 2020 project. That program includes development of a 50-state system of licensing and supervision for fintechs and other nonbanks. CSBS appointed a large fintech advisory group as part of its efforts.

Steve Cocheo

Steve Cocheo’s 39+ years in financial journalism have taken him to all 50 states and nearly every corner of financial services in companies from fintech startups to community banks to regional and national giants. He is executive editor of Banking Exchange and digital content manager of Previously he spent 36 years on the staff of ABA Banking Journal and 22 years concurrently as editor of ABA Bank Directors Briefing. He is the only journalist to have sat in on three federal banking exams, was a finalist for the Jesse H. Neal national business journalism awards, and a winner of multiple awards from the American Society of Business Publication Editors. In 2017 he received three awards from ASBPE: National Gold, National Bronze, and Regional Silver. Connect with Steve Cocheo and Banking Exchange on LinkedIn. Follow Banking Exchange on Twitter

back to top


About Us

Connect With Us


magazine Subscribe640 wstopshow Subscribe No Thanks Already Subscribed